Welcome to Gooey on The Inside Cookies
Gooey on The Inside Cookies is a delightful gem nestled in the heart of New York City, where cookie lovers can indulge in a variety of ooey-gooey treats. Born from a passion for baking, this tiny basement haven specializes in uniquely crafted cookies, featuring a plethora of flavors from classic Chocolate Chip Chunk to inventive Fruity Pebbles and decadent Dark Chocolate Caramel S'mores. With each bite, you experience a warm, melty center that entices the taste buds. The emphasis on quality ingredients and warmth elevates each cookie into an indulgent experience. For dessert enthusiasts seeking a sweet escape, Gooey on The Inside is a must-visit.
-
163 Chrystie St, New York, NY 10002 Hotline: (646) 972-0409
If you find yourself wandering the bustling streets of New York, there’s a hidden gem waiting just below the surface—literally! Introducing Gooey on The Inside Cookies, a delightful caterer located at 163 Chrystie St, NY, that has quickly gained a reputation for their mouthwatering creations. This snug takeaway spot is best described as a cookie lover’s paradise, offering a range of warm, gooey treats that are nothing short of spectacular.
What sets Gooey on The Inside Cookies apart?
- Warm Molten Cookie in a Jar: Their signature item is nothing short of genius. These jars house flavors like the Key Lime Pie and the rich PB & J S'mores, where gooey layers of chocolate, ganache, and ingenious flavor combinations coexist to create a heavenly experience. Each jar is priced at $14, making it not only decadent but also a unique dessert suitable for any occasion.
- Innovative Cookie Creations: Dive into their extensive list of cookies that will leave your taste buds dancing. Indulge in the Munch Dubai Chocolate, featuring a milk chocolate cookie with delectable pistachio cream, or the whimsically fun Chocolate Dunkaroo Cookie that evokes childhood nostalgia. Prices for these fantastic cookies start around $6, making them an accessible treat.
- Flavor of the Month: For the adventurous at heart, Gooey offers a rotating selection of unique flavors, ensuring that there’s always something new to savor. Whether it’s their seasonal specials or consistent crowd favorites like the Birthday Cake cookie, you’re bound to find a delight that speaks to you.
- Customer-Centric Experience: Despite its humble setting, the warmth of the service matches the cookies’ cozy vibe. Reviews highlight the dedication of the staff, who hustle tirelessly to ensure every cookie is served warm and with a smile.
What’s the buzz about?
Cusotmers rave about the Bueno Bueno cookie, a fan favorite loaded with Nutella, that is often touted as a must-try. Others share stories of their visits to this intimate establishment, noting the charm of its small basement location, a perfect setting for indulging in sweet treats with friends or family. With satisfied patrons like Jessica B. and Lauren R. singing its praises, it’s clear that this cookie haven is worth the visit. Whether you're on a sugar quest or searching for the perfect late-night snack, Gooey on The Inside Cookies is waiting to satisfy your cravings.
Insider Tip: For those looking to save, visit during the Happy Hour from Tuesday to Friday between 2-6 PM, where cookies can be enjoyed for only $5 each. It’s a delightful way to experience the scrumptious offerings at a sweeter price!
In a city filled with myriad culinary geniuses, Gooey on The Inside Cookies stands out with its playful, decadent, and lovingly crafted treats. Immerse yourself in their gooey goodness—you won't regret it.
A colleague mentioned this place when describing that it's located in a basement. It's a takeaway place--probably could fit three people max. I knew I wanted to try the chocolate chip because...well...it's a place that sells cookies. I had to try the chocolate chip cookies. I asked the employee what other cookies did he suggest. He mentioned a few and I decided to try the birthday cake cookie. They were $8 each so it was kind of a splurge but they were very good. The employee said that I could put it in the oven at 350 degrees for less than 10 minutes. I popped them in the air fryer for 2 minutes. I would go back and try some other flavors.
On a trip to NYC and staying in the Lower East Side, and my family was craving some cookies tonight. Found Gooey on the Inside on Yelp and it was the perfect spot! It's a tiny little takeout place in the basement, and they had about 10 different flavors to pick from. We got two to split among the 4 of us and it was the perfect amount. The Bueno Bueno was our favorite!
Stopped into gooey on the inside for a late night treat. Got myself a chocolate caramel smores cookie. I walked down the small stairwell and entered a small store with nothing more than a counter to serve customers up some cookies. The front is small because there is loads of cookie baking craziness going on in the back. Ovens, racks, doughs all sprawled out. It is wonderful. There was only 1 worker present and they were definitely stressed. Running around in maximum overdrive. I can always appreciate an employee that is overwhelmed, but still prioritizing the customer. Now, for the cookie. They serve their cookies warm because the center is supposed to be underbaked. So, they do not recommend eating them cold. These things are dense. Thick, gooey, and chewy. The cookie had a melted marshmallow atop with a gooey, caramel center. Some really solid ingredients, but the cookie did not knock my socks off. It was good, but certainly not the best I had while in NY. All in all, a decent cookie. But, I would probably roll with a regular chocolate chip next time!
$7 for a cookie seems pricey, even for NYC. But if you stop in between 2-6 on Tuesday-Friday during 'Happy Hour,' you can enjoy Gooey on the Inside's cookies for only $5 each (the four-for-three deal still applies). I love that this place has a variety of cookies but that the menu stays consistent from week to week. The only change is that Gooey offers a Cookie of the Month that changes. The Bueno Bueno was my favorite -- a rich combination of cookie and Nutella.
BEST COOKIE SPOT IN MANHATTAN! The flavors and the bake on the cookies are superb. Worth every penny! The oatmeal apple pie cookie was my absolutely favorite. Love that there's happy hours deals 4-6pm during the week. All cookie lovers especially those who enjoy a cookie with a gooey soft and flavorful bite, have to stop by.