Gooey on The Inside Cookies Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Gooey on The Inside Cookies, a must-visit dessert haven located at 163 Chrystie St, New York, NY. This charming takeaway spot specializes in warm, molten cookies designed to delight any sweet tooth.
Among their standout offerings is the Warm Molten Cookie in a Jar, featuring innovative flavors like the Key Lime Pie and Biscoff & Cream. Each jar holds layers of indulgence, perfect for sharing or a personal treat. The cookie selection includes enticing varieties like the Dark Chocolate Caramel S'mores and the newly introduced Banana Cream Pudding Cookie, which uniquely melds nostalgic flavors into a chewy delight.
With their celebrated happy hour deals and an ever-changing Cookie of the Month, each visit promises something special. The gooey perfection in every bite is irresistibly rewarding, making Gooey on The Inside Cookies a top destination for dessert lovers in Manhattan.
Cookies
Birthday Cake Cookie
6 oz. Now it can be your birthday everyday! This birthday cake cookie comes complete imported French white chocolate chunks, real birthday cake flavor, colorful sprinkles and an ooey-gooey center. You'll enjoy every last bite.
Chocolate Chip Chunk Cookie
6 oz. Our chocolate chip cookies are Melt-in-Your-Mouth! Rich dark and milk chocolate chips are combined with dark chocolate chunks in a delicious golden cookie.
Chocolate Dunkaroo Cookie
6 oz. You don't have to be a kid to love this cookie. It's full of milk chocolate chips, a creamy top layer of chocolate icing, a dusting of graham cracker crumbs and sprinkles. And let's not forget the Teddy Grahams to make it a legit Dunkaroo.
**NEW** Dark Chocolate Caramel S'mores Cookie
6 oz. Campfire not required! A sumptuous blend of French milk chocolate, dark chocolate, marshmallows, caramel and dark chocolate cookie make this childhood treat come to life. Ooey-Gooey perfection in every bite.
The Bueno Bueno ( The Good Good) Cookie
6 oz. Hazelnut cream filling, milk and dark chocolate and Kinder Bueno pieces
Biscoff and Cream
6 oz. *New flavor* Golden white chocolate cookie filled with Biscoff spread, topped with caramel buttercream and Biscoff crumbs
Straight Out of Chocton Cookie
6 oz. Triple dark chocolate glazed cookie, topped with Chocolate sprinkles
Flavor of the Munch Cookie
Ube Oreo : White chocolate, Ube and Oreo cookie chunks
**NEW**Fruity Pebbles Cheesecake Cookie
White chocolate cookie coupled with fruity pebbles and a cheese cake filling
**NEW** Banana Cream Pudding Cookie
Golden white chocolate cookies with golden oreo pieces, bananas and a custard filling
**NEW**Chocolate Moonpie Cookie
Graham cracker cookie with clusters of milk chocolate and marshmallow
**NEW**Apple Pie
Pieces of apples embedded in caramel, cinnamon and white chocolate.
**NEW** Apple Pie
**New** Banana Cream Pie
White chocolate cookie filled with chunks of mango, peach jam and pie crust infused with vanilla beans, cinnamon, brown butter and dark brown sugar.
**NEW**Custard Berry Tart
Sugar cookie filled with creamy custard and topped with berries.
**NEW**Red Velvet
Biscoff & Cream cookie
Flavor of the Munch
Dubai Chocolate: Milk choc cookie with pistachio cream filling
Birthday Cake Goowees (6 pcs)
Yummy birthday cake cookie bites complete with imported French white chocolate chunks and colorful sprinkles. You'll enjoy every last bite. Go Shorty! Its your birthday!
Chocolate Chip Chunk Goowees (6pcs)
Our chocolate chip cookie bites are Ooey Gooey Melt-in-Your-Mouth! Rich dark and milk chocolate chips are combined with dark chocolate chunks in a delicious golden.
**NEW**Dark Chocolate Caramel S'mores Goowees (6pcs)
Campfire not required! A sumptuous blend of French milk chocolate, dark chocolate, marshmallows, caramel and dark chocolate cookie make this childhood treat come to life. Ooey-Gooey perfection in every mini bite.
The Bueno Bueno Goowees (6pcs)
Hazelnut cream filling, milk and dark chocolate and Kinder Bueno cookie bites
Biscoff and Cream Goowees (6pcs)
Golden white chocolate cookie filled with biscoff and custard. Topped with biscoff cookie crumbs.
**NEW** Banana Goowees (6pcs)
**NEW**Fruity Pebbles Goowees (6pcs)
White chocolate cookie coupled with fruity pebbles and a cheese cake filling
**NEW**Banana Cream Pudding Goowees(6pcs)
Golden white chocolate cookies with golden oreo pieces, bananas and a custard filling
**NEW**Apple Pie Goowees(6pcs)
Flavor of the Munch Goowees(6pcs)
Raspberry and cream
**NEW**Red Velvet (6pcs)
**NEW**Biscoff & Cream Goowees (6 pcs)
Yummy birthday cake cookie bites complete with imported French white chocolate chunks and colorful sprinkles. You'll enjoy every last bite. Go Shorty! Its your birthday!
Flavor of the Month (6pcs)
Dubai Chocolate
Goowees
Warm Molten Cookie in a Jar
Birthday Cake Molten Cookie in a Jar
Warm molten chocolate and ganache layered between thick ooey gooey cookies.
Chocolate Chip Chunk Molten Cookie in a Jar
Warm molten chocolate and ganache layered between thick ooey gooey cookies.
The Bueno Bueno (The Good Good) Molten Cookie in a Jar **Contains Nuts**
Warm molten chocolate and ganache layered between thick ooey gooey cookies.
PB & J S'mores Molten Cookie in a Jar
Warm molten chocolate and ganache layered between thick ooey gooey cookies.
Dark Chocolate Caramel S'mores Molten Cookie in a Jar
Warm molten chocolate and ganache layered between thick ooey gooey cookies.
Chocolate Dunkaroo Molten Cookie in Jar
Warm molten chocolate and ganache layered between thick ooey gooey cookies.
Biscoff & Cream Molten Cookie in a Jar
Warm molten chocolate and ganache layered between thick ooey gooey cookies.
Fruity Pebbles Cheesecake Molten Cookie in a jar
White chocolate cookie coupled with fruity pebbles and a cheese cake filling
**NEW**Banana Cream Pudding Molten Cookie in a jar
Golden white chocolate cookies with golden oreo pieces, bananas and a custard filling
**NEW**Apple Pie in a Jar
Flavor of the Munch Molten Cookie in a Jar
Raspberry and cream
**NEW** Red Velvet Molten Cookie in a Jar
**NEW** Key Lime PieMolten Cookie in a Jar
Swirls of key lime pie filling , graham crackers and white chocolate make up this delicious cookie
**NEW**Biscoff & Cream Molten Cookie in a Jar
Birthday Cake a La Mode
Warm molten chocolate and ganache layered between thick ooey gooey cookies and vanilla ice cream
Chocolate Chip Chunk a La Mode
Warm molten chocolate and ganache layered between thick ooey gooey cookies and vanilla ice cream
Dark Chocolate Caramel S'Mores a La Mode
Warm molten chocolate and ganache layered between thick ooey gooey cookies and vanilla ice cream
Chocolate Dunkaroo a La Mode
Warm molten chocolate and ganache layered between thick ooey gooey cookies and vanilla ice cream
Biscoff & Cream a La Mode
Warm molten chocolate and ganache layered between thick ooey gooey cookies and vanilla ice cream
**NEW**Biscoff & Cream A la Mode
The Bueno Bueno (The Good Good) A La Mode ** Contains Hazelnuts**
Warm molten chocolate and ganache layered between thick ooey gooey cookies and vanilla ice cream
**NEW**Banana Cream Pie A la mode
**NEW**Banana Cream Pudding a la Mode
Golden white chocolate cookies with golden oreo pieces, bananas, custard filling and ice cream
**NEW**Red Velvet a la mode
**NEW** Apple Pie A la Mode
Flavor of the Munch A la Mode
Dubai Chocolate
Warm Molten Cookie in a Jar a la Mode (with Ice Cream)
Ice Cream Croissandwich
**NEW**Biscoff Ice Cream Croissandwich
Warm cookie dough, biscoff spread and vanilla ice cream sandwiched between a flaky buttery French croissant. Yum!
**NEW**Birthday Cake Ice Cream Croissandwich
Warm cookie dough, chocolate ganache and vanilla ice cream sandwiched between a flaky buttery French croissant. Yum!
**NEW**Chocolate Chip Chunk Ice Cream Croissandwich
Warm cookie dough, chocolate ganache and vanilla ice cream sandwiched between a flaky buttery French croissant. Yum!
**NEW**Dark Chocolate Caramel S'mores Ice Cream Croissandwich
Warm cookie dough, chocolate ganache, caramel, marshmallow fluff and vanilla ice cream sandwiched between a flaky buttery French croissant. Yum!
**NEW**Kinder Bueno Ice Cream Croissandwich (Contains Hazelnuts)
Warm cookie dough, nutella and vanilla ice cream sandwiched between a flaky buttery French croissant. Yum!
**NEW**Apple Pie Ice Cream Croissandwich
Flavor of the Munch Ice Cream Croissandwith
Dubai Chocolate